An interesting comparison. My Nikon AW1 developed a problem where the back panel buttons became unresponsive. I returned it for (warranty) repair. It took ages and in the meantime I bought an Olympus TG3 as a friend's camera I saw took really pleasing images. Welli, it did just that, took pleasing images. But on inspecting at 100% they were pretty ordinary with significant smearing and loss of detail. A week or so ago Nikon replaced my Nikon AW1 with a new one. Soooo much better. Not DSLR quality but significantly better than "the rest" .
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.